I love bees.
I planted a bee-friendly garden on purpose. I worry about the die-off of the planet’s pollinators. I’ve had bees in my gardens for most of my life, and I want them there. (Wasps are another matter. Wasps, I’ll destroy.)
About a month ago I was out trimming dead roses so they’d bloom one more time before the end of the season. Weeding. Cleaning up.
And I was swarmed by the most vicious bees I have ever met.
I never saw a hive. I was stung badly, and several of them died driving me off. We thought they were wasps at first, which would have made things simple. But they left their stingers behind, and only bees do that.
So I stayed out of that corner. The roses didn’t get their last bloom. The weeds moved in. I put down a little weed block at the edges, a bit at a time, and told myself the bees had probably moved on.
Hold on to that corner of the garden. I’m coming back to it.
Meanwhile…
I spend time in online forums for creatives. I love spending time with authors and artists. Most of these spaces are designed for readers and writers, artists and art lovers, to come together. Some even have marketplaces where writers can find artists to hire. Brilliant, beautiful spaces.
But I’ve also seen a dark side to these spaces. Someone uses an AI piece as a quick illustration, a sample of what could be, and the attacks begin. One person objects, and then a swarm, despite the many people who’ve already gotten the point and moved on.
The use of AI at all is treated as an insult to artists, and they are leaving because of it. They don’t see the message behind whatever the example is. They only see AI, or what they suspect might be AI.
They forget the time spent connecting with authors and building a connection where everyone works together. Insults start. Both sides feel disrespected and undervalued.
The fight becomes one of protecting a home. In the best spaces, they find a compromise and apologize. In the worst ones, people leave in protest.
My heart aches to see these situations, because both sides have lost something important, and both sides have also lost respect. This makes me angry, and puts me in a state of mind that I don’t usually let myself write from.
Later…
My daughter came out to help me weed. She accidentally uncovered the opening to an underground hive, in what was probably an old rodent burrow, and those bees attacked her in the way they’d attacked me.
Now I knew where they were, and I knew why they were attacking.
I called beekeepers who relocate hives. Every one of them was overloaded with bees that needed moving, and nobody wanted more.
(Regular readers will remember the weasel in my office. The wildlife center reports that the babies were all raised to adulthood and released into the wild. They were thriving the last time anyone saw them. I wanted that ending for the bees.)
They couldn’t be moved and they couldn’t stay. You can’t explain to a hive that you’d happily leave it alone if it would just stop attacking.
There’s no reasoning with bees.
So I went to the garden store and bought enough poison to destroy them all.
Do I feel bad? Yes. Do I regret the necessity? Yes. That part of the garden is mine again, and it didn’t have to go that way.
As I bought that spray, I recognized the feeling of anger and protectiveness that was driving me. I’d had it in the creative space, watching a person I cared about get stung by people she loved.
I don’t want to feel about people the way I ended up feeling about that hive. So I’m writing this instead.
Where the bees stop being useful
The bees saw me in their space and did the only thing bees can do. Attack, and bring everyone. They believed that driving off the threat would make them safe. It got them destroyed.
This forum discussion went differently. Everyone apologized and peace was at least temporarily restored.
Bees can’t do that. People can.
I understand the fear. AI is disruptive, and it is a threat to people who make their living from art and words. I wrote a whole book about the worries (Reflections from the Mirror). But AI is also here, and it’s staying. Pandora’s box has been opened. The most disruptive technology is here. We can use it or not.
What happened when I talked about AI
This summer I published a piece called “My Writing Is Human. I Also Use AI.”
About ten people wrote to me privately. Some just said thank you. The longer notes kept using the same word.
Brave.
One came from someone who draws as well as writes, and uses AI to look over their own sketches for the little things they’ve missed. Another uses it to brainstorm. Both made a point of telling me that the AI doesn’t write the words or draw the lines. One said it three times in a short note. Both said they’d never admit any of it in public, because they aren’t that brave.
They were writing to the one person they already knew was safe, and they were still pleading their case.
And then the thing I’d braced for didn’t happen.
No one has come for me. At all.
Maybe I’m safe. Maybe I’m not successful enough for anyone to feel I’m stepping on their hive. I don’t know, and I can’t promise it’s safe to walk in the garden again. I know authors who’ve had to build whole systems to keep their social media civil.
But about ten people wrote to me as though each one was the only one.
What the stinging wins
Nobody in any of these stories stopped using AI. They stopped saying so.
I hired a cover artist for a project that also used AI images, because the budget couldn’t cover all human art and we bought as much as we could. A client who uses AI for advertising just hired an artist to create a custom cover for an upcoming book. Another book hired an artist to correct and repair AI designs, and the author ended up with something professional at a price the author could manage.
Each time, the choice was budget based. If we had money for an artist, we gave it to the human.
I can’t tell you who any of them are. It isn’t safe for them yet.
The fear doesn’t stay on one side, either. This summer a debut novelist lost a seven-figure book deal when his own agents couldn’t verify how he’d used AI. He says he used it for research. In September a novel came off the longlist for France’s biggest literary prize after an anonymous account ran it through a detection tool. The author says he wrote the first draft in 2019.
A forum I used to visit bans AI outright. The last time I looked, its members had a discussion going about how to protect themselves from being accused of using AI, because even they aren’t safe. You see, they viciously attack anyone who uses AI, and now they are being attacked for being suspected of using it.
Nobody feels safe on either side of this.
I’ve watched places where writers gathered empty out before. NaNoWriMo closed last year after a long slide, and the fight over AI was one of the things that went wrong at the end. A home like that doesn’t get knocked down. People leave, each for a good reason, until nobody’s left.
The corner I stopped tending
Remember that corner of my garden?
I’m hiding from the bees, too.
There are many places I no longer visit because I feel that those who use AI are not welcome. And when I see a seal on a cover certifying that no AI touched the book, I put the book down. The author never finds out. Nobody writes a letter that says I didn’t buy your book.
Nobody buys poison. People just quietly slip away.
So I have a question, and I’m asking myself first. What would it take to walk back into that corner of my garden?
I’d need to feel safe again. And with bees? There’s only one way. But with humans? We can adapt.
If you’ve been stinging, look at who you’re stinging. Someone in your critique group is using AI and can’t tell you. Or maybe they’ve just quietly left the group. They might have insights and ways to help you grow your business, but they can’t tell you that, either.
If you’ve been hiding, I can only tell you what happened to me. I shared how I used AI, about ten people thanked me, and nobody threw anything. (Yet. Comparing them to bees may be pushing my luck.)
I want all artists to thrive. A true creative with the help of an AI is more powerful than a creative alone. But even if you never touch it, we still need you. In the future of tomorrow (wink), we’re going to need human art and human creativity more than we ever have.
My garden is thriving, and I want it to stay that way. For that, I’m going to need bees.
(I’d just ask them to build somewhere other than the middle of the path. Then we can all be safe in the garden.)



IMO, those bees work as an apt metaphor for an internet pile-on. The group behavior of the angry bees is more about them than their target. I'm glad you and your family are safe from those bees.
Im adding bee hives to the homestead in northern California next season planting a fruit orchard they will help pollinate and the honeycomb produced is grest for local seasonal allergy.